Simple bread for everyone

Welcome to Crumbstead: Your Sourdough Journey

✓ Simple Recipes for Beginners

✓ Tips for Urban Homesteading

✓ Clear Guidance for Every Step

Join Our Sourdough Journey Today!

Discover the Joy of Sourdough Baking with Us!

Start Baking Now!

Sourdough Starter Basics (Without the Fuss)

If you’re just getting into sourdough baking, welcome! It’s easy to get overwhelmed with all the advice out there about starters — daily feedings, discards, complicated schedules. But honestly? It doesn’t have to be that serious.

Start With a Good Starter

My #1 tip: get a strong, healthy starter from someone else — a baker friend, a local bakery, a farmer’s market, or even online. Making your own starter from scratch can work, but it takes time and sometimes a lot of trial and error. If you can get your hands on one that’s already alive and kicking, you’ll skip straight to the fun part: baking.

(But hey — if you can’t find one nearby, you can totally grow your own. It just might take a little patience.)

What’s “Discard” and Why Should You Care?

You’ll hear the term “discard” tossed around a lot. It just means the extra starter you’re not using when you feed it. That’s it. No mystery. No shame. And no, you absolutely don’t need to stockpile it like it’s sourdough gold.

If you’re smart with how you feed your starter, you won’t end up with tons of discard anyway.

Feeding Your Starter — The Lazy (But Smart) Way

The standard feeding ratio is 1:1:1 — starter:water:flour. But here’s the important bit:

⚠️ This ratio is by weight, not volume.
That means you need a kitchen scale.

Yes, I know — I love a gadget-free kitchen too. But trust me here: a kitchen scale is worth it. They’re inexpensive, small, and super useful for all kinds of things (cooking, jam, baking, fermenting, you name it). Trying to measure starter with cups just doesn’t work well — it’s sticky, bubbly, and inaccurate.

Now, I don’t always follow the textbook 1:1:1 myself. Here’s what I actually do:

If I need 100g of starter for a recipe, I just feed my whole jar with 50g water and 50g flour — I don’t even check how much starter is in there. It always works, and I don’t end up with loads of discard.

I usually keep about 100g of starter in the fridge, because most of my recipes call for 100–200g. But if I need more? I feed it more. Simple.

When Is Your Starter Ready to Use?

The sweet spot is when your starter has at least doubled in size and hasn’t started collapsing yet.

The easiest way to track this? Use a straight-sided glass jar and mark the starting point with a rubber band. It makes it super easy to see when it’s risen enough.

Bonus trick: Drop a spoonful into a glass of water — if it floats, it’s ready to bake.

But honestly, even if you miss that ideal “doubled and bubbly” moment, it’ll still work. It might take a little longer to ferment your dough, but you’ll still get great bread. I’ve used starter straight from the fridge after two months of neglect — no problem.

Keeping It Alive (Without the Pressure)

Here’s what I do after baking: I just pop the starter back in the fridge and leave it there until I need it again. No daily feeding. No stress.

Personally, I’ve gone a month without needing my precious starter, and it bounced back just fine after a single feeding. But some brave souls on Reddit have left theirs in the fridge for 4 to 6 months or more, and still brought them back to life with a couple of feedings.

If it’s been a while and you’re feeling a little guilty but not ready to bake bread — no problem. Just feed it once and use the extra in pancakes, waffles, crackers, whatever. It gets refreshed, you don’t waste anything, and you get breakfast out of the deal.

That’s it! Keep your starter alive, don’t overthink the discard, and don’t worry about perfection. A little flour, a little water, a scale, and some patience — that’s all you need.

Highlights

Start with a strong, healthy starter from someone else.

Feed your starter 1:1 ratio of water and flour by weight.

Skip the discard pile by feeding only as much as you need for your recipe.

Use a straight-sided glass jar and a rubber band to track its rise.

Only feed it when you need it — no daily schedule required.

Store it in the fridge between bakes — it can rest for weeks (or longer).